Saturday, 23 December 2017

LEADERSHIP AND LAUNCESTON COUNCIL AND THE SHOW

Launceston’s Council’s leadership is a figment of somebody’s imagination and its not to be found anywhere near Town Hall. 

Council rounded off its year by licensing itself to do whoever’s bidding in secret and behind closed doors. 

Taking away constituent's opportunities to engage with council in fulsome free flowing community discourses via fortnightly Strategic Planning and Policy Committee meetings, well that was swept away like so many autumn leaves in a park on a windy day. 

This screws down the lid on the coffin that holds the remains of all hope for a meaningful critical discourse in the city.

Aldermen sprooking up their credentials as ‘elected decision makers’ seem to quickly assume that they have the social licence to do whatever it is they want well away from public scrutiny and behind tightly closed doors. 

Rumour and critical banter has the Mayor and Aldermen McKenzie, McKendrick and Finlay (and presumably others too) as the most often reported for such self-serving rhetoric – and it comes in various shapes and forms. At best this stuff is 'dumbed down schoolyard politics' unworthy of supposed grown-ups or even elected representative of a community such as Launceston.

Just try and contact an Launceston alderman other than on some designated occasion and you're likely to get a dumbed-down recorded message telling you how busy they are. Approach one at a public event and as often as not they'll find themselves in a deep private conversation, or they'll tell you they need to keep on circulating, or they'll tell you they have all the good oil and your concerns are trivial and totally unfounded. Worse still, they'll tell you it’s an "operational matter" that they cannot discuss with you as it’s in the hands of the General Manager and other officers. 

Then approach the GM, or any other council officer, and they're likely to tell you, if you hold an alternative view to themselves, count to three and wait for them to tell you to "talk to an alderman" or put your concerns in writing. Either way you’ve been fobbed off!

As time passes the tools of obfuscation become sharper and sharper. In the end, you have nothing to do but to continue to pay up and shut up – well that's the plan. If you do not, there is always the latent promise to 'sell you up' or 'come down on you like a ton of bricks' under some regulation or other. All the time 'council' surrounds itself with its self-congratulatory 'values' assumed to put 'council' way, way beyond criticism and critique – and to see you off in a flash ... LINK HERE.

How can you argue with anyone in power who claims to be telling you 'the truth' even though you've got copious evidence to counter such assertions?

All this is just a backdrop to three years of the increasingly evident dumbing down of council matters in Launceston.  Discretionary accountability is in practice at Launceston's Town Hall and its selling ratepayers very short. In accountability terms, four years of ‘all-in-all-out’ councils, have proven to be a disaster in so much as it has clearly propagated uninhibited hubris and a sense contemptuousness in regard to 'the constituency' with elections always quite a way away. 

Launceston's final council meeting for 2017 was a rolled gold exemplar of just about everything that a constituency would hope not to find in Local Government. The Mayor trying to smooth things over after the fact in the press and on TV might be as they say, 'suckering the punters' – well some of them. However, in the longer term its less and less likely to ‘cut it’ given that the constituency, on the evidence, is not nearly as dumb as the aldermen's beliefs and hopes for them. Also, they, 'the punters', are increasingly better connected via social media than most aldermen iy seems.

As for the projected demise of the Launceston Show, this is where the council has not done itself proud in the 'leadership stakes'. And this is not something that has just exhibited itself, it's been a background issue for quite some time. 

One might think that in a city like Launceston its council might be looking to promote the city more proactively via such events. 

‘Show Week’ in Launceston was once a boom time and it could be again.

One would think that a council might want to tap into the city's history and heritage wherever it could. With 144 years of history, Launceston show might well be seen as a rich opportunity to promote the city rather than dumbing down everything and characterising ‘The Show’ as being a liability and a drain on 'council funds'. 

Sadly, this dumbing down is on a relentless spiral downwards and heading nowhere interesting. 

Sure, 'agricultural shows' might need to be 'reimagined' in the way 'The Gorge' is currently being 'reimagined'. In order that 'The Show' might win 21st Century relevance, and audience support, change will be needed – and it’s very doable. 'The Show' is a part of Launceston's cultural heritage but it's highly unlikely that Launceston' exGM, Robert Dobrzynski, would have been inclined to include anything about it in his brief to Robin Archer (Cultural Consultant) who, apparently, is currently developing a 'cultural strategy' for the city.

No, no, no, as someone from somewhere else such things are unlikely to cross one's mind and something more gets whittled away when this lot of aldermen look away – or perhaps are playing some other game rather than representing their constituents.

However, the financial suffocation of 'The Show Society' has been ongoing for some time. And, despite the new GM's assurances that "Council has [not] engineered the steady decline of the Royal Launceston Show" anyone with their ear to the ground could be excused for thinking otherwise. Then again, he'd have to say wouldn't he?!

Launceston Council has only ever offered token support as other forces coveted 'Show Society land'. In fact, Aldermen McKenzie and Alexander watched over the demise (some say an orchestrated demise) of YPIPA (York Park and Inveresk Precinct Authority) the ‘council body’ that once championed 'The Show'. Unsurprisingly, the event's future has been becoming increasingly bleak with all this going on in the background one shouldn't be surprised.

Given YPIPA's vision was to see the Inveresk precinct as a "vibrant cultural centre for Entertainment, Education and Recreation", YPIPA's summary demolition as an 'authority' saw the prospect of 'The Show' having its future undermined and increasingly– and becoming more and more tenuous. 

So much for local culture, so much for the aspirations of ordinary Launcestonians. When one-dimensional dumb and muddle headed thinking seems to hold the trump card it’s hard to see a way forward – nor indeed would there be any room for logic.

Given all that is at stake, what should have happened long ago was a community consultation process tasked to find a new way forward for 'The Show' given all the signals and the 'flashing warning lights' telling us that such a thing was needed. That the city of Launceston's Council has been missing in action, its inaction is palpable. Given all the signals that such a thing was, and arguably still is, very much needed, just what is holding it back? 

Interestingly, the Royal National Agricultural and Pastoral Society (RNAPS) still holds the key cards in this unmistakably sinister game of chance.  What would allow such a process to begin? As for the so-called 'devastating debt' to the Council, well that could be paid off over time. As for raising funds, options exist. As for what 'The Show’ might look like that’s something worth exploring.

In all this the City of Launceston's Council has been missing and its recalcitrance is palpable. 

Given Council’s lack of leadership, and Council’s community disconnect, 'The Show’ is only likely survive as an event with cultural significance in Launceston if the community works with the RNAPS. Council could facilitate that but apparently its a looking away with other things in mind – maybe that's a bridge too far.

The very notion that the proposed University of Tasmania’s relocation not being a factor in the decision to refuse a financial request from the RNAPS, well it is implausible. To help host the Launceston Show in 2018 the City of Launceston is blighted by it own serial and demonstrated disregard for 'The Show'. Among Council's unfolding visions, visions that are largely only ever discussed 'in secret' it seems, one wonders just how grotty all this is yet to get.

Council's decision, again behind closed doors, to knock back a proposal for Council to buy back the Launceston Showgrounds lease was as sinister as it is malevolent. Yet, the notion that the show could not go on without the support of Council given the financial situation is challengeable.

And then there is this breaking news
FROM BASIL FITCH'S FACEbook: "Newnham university campus to be bulldozed for housing! Fire Brigade asked to assess the whole campus site for housing! 

  • What is the real truth about the refusal by Launceston City Council to support the Show Society? 
  • Where does the truth really lie with the UTas Newnham Campus and Inveresk? 
Multi millions of dollars wasted and more being wasted. SCAM!!!!! Commercial-in-confidence - Van Zetten reveals that the Show Society debt is $100,000. 

University so-called Master Plan July 2017 clearly marks 750 car parking spaces on the Show Society's land! 

Lies, lies and more damn lies!" ... https://www.facebook.com/search/top/?q=launceston%20city%20council


LINKS THUS FAR


Wednesday, 20 December 2017

More Secret Meetings For Launceston's Council

This news is a total denial of community access to their representatives.  The workshops being flagged in this story are in fact what was once called 'cutting and drying sessions'. Whatever, they are a denial of accountability and transparency and and an exemplar of 'discretionary accountability'.

Also,  this Council seems to be totally committed to secret backroom dealing contorary to its publish "values" ... https://www.launceston.tas.gov.au/Council/Our-Vision-Mission-and-Values.  See this on the CoL Website and think it through! Likewise, keep this quote in mind as you ponder these values ... “A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody.” Thomas Paine

 Vision
Launceston is proud of its heritage and is a vibrant and inclusive community that is creative and sustainable, inspired by its diverse opportunities and rich natural environment.
Mission
We work together as one organisation to deliver quality and innovative services to our community.
Values
Integrity
  • We behave ethically
  • We tell the truth
  • We keep our commitments
  • We meet both the spirit and intent of the law
Stewardship
  • We care about people and the community in which we live
  • We operate safely
  • We are environmentally responsible
  • We strengthen the community   
Inclusion
  • We value diversity and respect the dignity of each person
  • We value differences in people and perspectives
  • We build relationships based on mutual trust
  • We recognise the contributions of every individual 
Initiative
  • We lead the way
  • We have the courage and creativity to shape the future
  • We have the discipline to manage risk
  • We act decisively in a timely manner
Teamwork
  • We work together to achieve superior results
  • We share ideas and talents to develop solutions
  • We support and rely on each other
  • We value clear and open communication 
Accountability
  • We take responsibility for our actions
  • We live our values
  • We set clear goals, measure results and seek to improve
  • We build and protect the Launceston brand and reputation 
                   

FROM THE EXAMINER

The Strategic Planning and Policy Committee will no longer operate

Launceston's Town Hall
 Launceston's Town Hall
The city council’s Strategic Planning and Policy Committee will be disbanded due to the public nature of its meetings.
Alderman agreed at Monday’s council meeting that it was difficult for matters to be discussed freely since the SPPC was first opened to the public in 2013.
“Indeed, the public nature of these meetings has caused issues for the council whereby matters are being prematurely released into the public realm before the council and council officers are able to thoroughly work through issues together,” the meeting agenda said.
“Accordingly, it is considered that the current SPPC is not fulfilling its primary purpose of providing a forum for aldermen and senior officers to consider significant long-term policy matters and as such it may be a more appropriate use of time and resources to dissolve the SPPC special committee in favour of council workshops.”
Council workshops are closed to the public and are often held at the conclusion of the committee meetings. 
“The opening up of the SPPC meetings to members of the public has caused fewer and fewer matters to be directed to these meetings,” the agenda said.
In 2015 the former general manager Robert Dobrzynski told The Examinerthe council was “in favour of transparency, which is why we have opened our SPPC meetings to the public …”
Many stories written by journalists at The Examiner have been sourced from information gathered at SPPC meetings.
Some of those from 2017 alone include:

Monday, 18 December 2017

IT'S CHRISTMAS: Should we laugh or should we cry?

JUST A COPY OF A POST ON SPEAK UP LAUNCESTON AFTER BEING MADE AWARE OF THE SP&P COMMITTEE ITEM ON THE COUNCIL AGENDA MONDAY 17 DEC. 
Anyone on Facebook might want to share the Speak Up post around.

Should we laugh or should we cry?  But its Christmas next week!

Part of the City Council's Strategic Plan 2014-2024 claims to be an 'accountable and responsive Organisation' and to 'ensure decisions are made in a transparent and accountable way' etc. 

Speak Up L'ton has been alerted to a couple of items on the agenda for this Monday's City Council meeting - the last Council meeting for the year 2017 (17 Dec). 

Of concern is the recommendation in Agenda Item 21.3 to 'disband the Strategic Planning & Policy Committee.' At the moment, the SP&P committee is generally open to the public, but can also go into closed sessions. 

But now the plan is to get rid of it altogether (Agenda pages 129-131)

The second concern is about the Show Society's Show Report 2017 which was discussed in a Council Workshop on 11 Dec. 

In relation to this on Monday is Item 23.2, when the public council meeting goes behind closed doors - Closed Council (no members of the public allowed thank you) to discuss the Show Society's RNAPS Report to Council. 

Why Closed Council? Because they can. Regulation 15(2)(c) says that "commercial information of a confidential nature that, if disclosed, is likely to: 
(i) prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it; or 
(ii) confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council; or 
(iii) reveal a trade secret." - 'transparent'? 'accountable'? 'communicate and engage'... 'with community and stakeholders'? 'champion collaboration'? 

Back to the first question - should we laugh or cry? "


Sunday, 17 December 2017

Merry Christmas: City of Launceston COUNCIL AGENDA Monday 18 December 2017 130 21.3


CLICK HERE TO MAKE THE LINK
Reading this agenda item and just before Christmas you just know that your council has your best interests at heart. Who needs to know all the ins and outs of council business and especially so while the cutting and drying is going on. 

You see Strategic Planning and Policy Committee meetings should be arranged so all that goes on quite quietly and well away the rabble and to avoid the annoyance that too many ratepayers cause. 

Workshops (definition yet to be provided) are the place where the officers can pull those aldermen who are inclined to listen to their constituents into line. You see confidentiality without too much accountability is what is required for efficiency and effective management. Anyway, most constituents never read council agendas and when they do get to them they find them unedifying and somewhat obtuse. 

Do not worry quite a few (most?) aldermen do not bother to read them either and some even boast they do not as there is no point since they are there for the record only. Thus they are of minimal use. The real stuff is never written down because that sort of thing only gets one into trouble. 

But anyway here we go look at this agenda item to see what you can make of it.  It is after all  Christmas!

"21.3 Action in Respect of the Strategic Planning and Policy Committee FILE NO: SF3108

AUTHOR: John Davis (Manager Corporate Strategy) 

GENERAL MANAGER: Michael Stretton (General Manager)

  • DECISION STATEMENT: To consider disbanding the Strategic Planning and Policy Committee.   
  • PREVIOUS COUNCIL CONSIDERATION: Pre-Council Workshop - 4 December 2017
  • RECOMMENDATION: That Council disbands the Strategic Planning and Policy Committee. 
 REPORT: The General Manager met with Aldermen on 4 December 2017 to discuss the possibility of disbanding the Strategic Planning and Policy Committee (SPPC). The SPPC has been in operation for many years having initially been established as a Special Committee under section 24 of the Local Government Act 1993 (the Act). 


The Council's former Governance Arrangement Policy and Strategic Planning and Policy Committee Policy initially set out the parameters of the Committee, namely that: 
  • Its role was to consider and discuss significant long-term policy matters and make recommendations to Council; 
  • It comprised membership of Aldermen and Council Directors; 
  • Was provided with no delegated authority; and 
  • Its Meetings were to be held in closed session. 
In 2013 the Council revised the arrangements for the SPPC to achieve compliance with the former Local Government (Meeting Procedures) Regulations 2005 (Regulations). 

The revised arrangements included the following changes: 
  • The Committee was formed under section 23 of the Act as a Council Committee and therefore the representatives were limited to Aldermen; 
  • Notices of meetings were published in The Examiner; 
  • Meetings were open to the public; 
  • An ability for the Committee to make a decision to enter into a Closed Meeting; 
  • Minutes to be generated and managed in accordance with the regulations. 
 Since this time the Council has operated the SPPC under the above-mentioned terms, however, it has also conducted Aldermen Workshops following the conclusion of the Council Committee Meetings. 

In practice, the opening up of the SPPC Meetings to members of the public has caused fewer and fewer matters to be directed to these Meetings. This is due to the public nature of the Meetings which has made it difficult for Aldermen and staff to freely discuss and work through matters. 

Indeed, the public nature of these Meetings has caused issues for the Council whereby matters are being prematurely released into the public realm before the Council and Council officers are able to thoroughly work through issues together. 

Accordingly, it is considered that the current SPPC is not fulfilling its primary purpose of providing a forum for Aldermen and Senior Officers to 'consider significant long-term policy matters' and as such it may be a more appropriate use of time and resources to dissolve the SPPC Special Committee in favour of Council Workshops. 

ECONOMIC IMPACT: Not considered relevant to this report. 
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: Not considered relevant to this report. 
SOCIAL IMPACT: Not considered relevant to this report."

Monday, 11 December 2017

Gutwein, TASwater, UTas & THE Council

Now we know why the Launceston City Council abstained from voting with the 25 councils against Gutwein's takeover of Taswater. 

Gutwein and his gang of proponents has given Launceston's combined stormwater-sewerage systems to Infrastructure Tasmania and his plan is to take over TasWater and sewerage in order to bypass any problems blocking the UTas development at Inveresk. 

But Gutweins' Bill was defeated 10-4 in the Legislative Council. So this sneaky deal has now all blown up in their face. 

Any development application will still come under scrutiny as per any other planning regulations. 

LCC were prepared to sell out the ratepayers and take away Taswater dividends of $5.5m - $180 a year each ratepayer. 

LCC has been complicit in all these backdoor deals! Gutwein now plans to make it an election issue. 

Don't let them sell your asset. Say no to their shonky deals! Vote against any party or candidate who supports the Liberal Government on this issue. "Walk a crooked mile..."

There are a few questions stemming from this: 
  • Why did Launceston City Council abstain when 25 councils voted to retain Taswater and only 2-3 Councils voted for Govt takeover? 
  • Whose idea was it to hand the Launceston system over to Infrastructure Tasmania? 
  • Why did Launceston City Council hand the system over. 
  • Who ordered the handover? 
  • Did the aldermen vote for it? 
 Infrastructure Tas is part of State Growth Dept.

D Bowen

Wednesday, 29 November 2017

Invermay Traffic

THE Invermay Traffic Investigation Report is due to be completed by the end of 2017 (The Examiner, November 14). 

It would seem the intersection of Lindsay and Goderich Streets which is adjacent to Charles Street Bridge is the worst performing intersection in Launceston, this is before any further development such as the Silo's complex and planned expansion in the area abounding Bunnings.

Will a similar study be initiated at the Tamar Bridge end of Lindsay Street? Not according to the City of Launceston Council at its meeting on November 21.

They intend to whack some traffic lights up and then hope that the area can cope with the 30,000-plus vehicle movements a day, this is before the UTAS campus is built, which will add another 15,000-plus.

Is the campus considered a poor cousin to an hotel development, it does seem that some intersections are more equal than others.

Ron Baines, Kings Meadows.


Monday, 30 October 2017

THE GLENORCHY STORY ROLLS ON!!

Note: As this story unfolds there is no question that receivers of supposed local Govt. services are the one who stump up and are usually required to shut up! The more roils out the more we see evidence that accountability and the lack of it is the issue. Too much is being invested in achieving far too little and its about time that it stops.

 

There is more to the story in Glenorchy Council tender drama

Greg Barns, Mercury  October 30, 2017 1:00am

 

One feels for Peter Brooks. The general manager of the Glenorchy City Council has been subjected to a relentless campaign designed to paint him as a person with little integrity. As is often the case with such campaigns the truth can be very different indeed.

 

Only a fortnight ago Mr Brooks and a company chaired by former Victorian premier Jeff Kennett made front page news

 

On October 17 the Mercury reported Auditor-General Rod Whitehead had delivered a report in which he expressed concern about the fact the engagement by Mr Brooks and the council of CT Management, a company specialising in local government change management services, without going to tender, "lacked transparency" and failed to comply with the Local Government Act and council's code for procurement.

 

The value of the work is said to be just over $1 million.

 

The Auditor-General said there was evidence of splitting contracts so they were under the amounts of $250,000 and $100,000 respectively — the amounts specified in the Local Government Act and the Council's Code as being when tender provisions operate.

 

The report was great news for former Glenorchy mayor Kristy Johnston, a populist politician, and her friend in government, Local Government Minister Peter Gutwein.

 

What Ms Johnston and the critics of Mr Brooks and CT Management have not said is that in January councillors received legal advice from a senior member of the Tasmanian Bar, Bruce McTaggart SC, that took a different view of the council's arrangement with CT Management.

 

Mr McTaggart was asked to advise on whether the council's engagement of CT Management in 2015-16, which was done without tender, and which resulted in the latter being paid $445,515.84 for work done, was compliant with provisions of relevant codes and legislation.

 

Mr McTaggart's very thorough advice concluded that the splitting of work, heavily criticised by the Auditor-General, was in fact justified. This is because each piece of work done by CT Management was for a "totally different scope of works".

 

In fact, because the council had resolved to accept the work CT Management was doing and going to do, it would "not have been reasonable" for Mr Brooks to have wasted ratepayer funds on tenders.

 

The council did not have to reveal the contracts with CT Management in its 2015-16 annual report, Mr McTaggart concluded, because none of the contracts exceeded $100,000. And, he concluded "engagement of CTMG during the 2015/16 financial year were complaint with public tender requirements" under relevant legislation.

 

Mr McTaggart's advice paints a different picture of the CT Management issue and involvement of Mr Brooks.

 

While the Auditor-General might take a different view it does not mean he is necessarily correct. Tendering processes and whether there is a need to tender are often issues about which there are varying opinions because the rules provide a fair degree of discretion.

 

Perhaps those who are gunning for Mr Brooks, and it seems Mr Kennett indirectly, should examine all the facts and understand the regulatory regimes driving tender processes.

If they did and were able to put aside their prejudices then a more nuanced and considered view of the Glenorchy council mess would emerge.

 

There is another aspect that should trouble anyone with an interest in democracy.

 

That is the decision by Mr Gutwein to indicate new elections for councillors would be on January 16. To hold an election in the middle of the holiday season where there may be a number of new candidates is undemocratic.

 

Speaking of elections, this Saturday the Legislative Council seat of Pembroke is up for grabs. Hans Willink, a genuine liberal, is running. Mr Willink stands for open markets, small government and social liberalism.

 

He is a rare breed in this community where big government and social conservatism go hand in glove.

 

If you support a reduction in the scope of government activity, a preparedness to stand up to lobby groups, and policymaking based on evidence, not prejudice and fear, then Mr Willink is the candidate you should support.

 

Greg Barns is a human rights lawyer. He has advised state and federal Liberal governments.

 

 

Glenorchy aldermen set to learn their resignation fate

SIMEON THOMAS-WILSON, Mercury October 23, 2017 10:21pm

 

THE future of the suspended Glenorchy aldermen who attempted to resign last week is set to be known on Tuesday.

 

Tasmanian Electoral Commissioner Andrew Hawkey will make an announcement regarding the eligibility of the seven Glenorchy aldermen to resign from their positions before they are sacked, should legislation introduced by the Government enabling it do to do so get through Parliament.

 

Following the move by Local Government Minister Peter Gutwein, seven Glenorchy aldermen — Steve King, Jenny Branch-Allen, Harry Quick, Christine Lucas, David Pearce, Stuart Slade and Haydyn Nielsen — all submitted their resignations to the council.

 

But Director of Local Government Alex Tay said they couldn't resign.

 

In response to a joint statement issued by six of the seven on Sunday, Glenorchy Commissioner Sue Smith said they had not been denied the right to resign, rather the council had to get legal advice as to what impact a mass resignation would have regarding a potential by-election.

 

Mr King, Ms Branch-Allen and Mr Slade said council staff only forwarded their resignations to Mr Hawkey when they engaged the services of a barrister to pursue their cases for resignation.

 

Mr Slade, a former mayor of Glenorchy, said he was "staggered" by the response from Mr Tay and council staff.

 

"We are confident in the legal advice we got," he said.