Monday, 18 September 2017

Has UTas turned into "aimless, money-grubbing exploiter of students"??

SOURCE
"The first of the budget-relieving measures was the least objectionable: introducing the Higher Education Contribution Scheme, requiring students – who gain significant private benefits from their degrees – to bear just some of the cost of those degrees, under a deferred loan-repayment scheme carefully designed to ensure it did nothing to deter students from poor families.
Likewise, allowing unis to admit suitably qualified overseas students provided they paid full freight was unobjectionable in principle. [Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
John Howard continued the Hawke-Keating push on universities.

The Howard government's scheme allowing less qualified local students to be admitted provided they paid a premium was "problematic", as the academics say, and soon abandoned.
The problem is that continuing cuts in government grants to unis have kept a protracted squeeze on uni finances, prompting vice-chancellors to become obsessed with money-raising.
They pressure teaching staff to go easy on fee-paying overseas students who don't reach accepted standards of learning, form unhealthy relationships with business interests, and accept "soft power" grants from foreign governments and their nationals without asking awkward questions.[Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
They pressure academics not so much to do more research as to win more research funding from the government. Interesting to compare the hours spent preparing grant applications with the hours actually doing research. [Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
A total of eight Australian universities have been listed among the top 100 in the QS Graduate Employability Rankings.

To motivate the researchers, those who bring in the big bucks are rewarded by being allowed to pay casuals to do their teaching for them. (This after the vice-chancellors have argued straight-faced what a crime it would be for students to be taught by someone who wasn't at the forefront of their sub-sub research speciality.)
The unis' second greatest crime is the appalling way they treat those of their brightest students foolish enough to aspire to an academic career. Those who aren't part-timers are kept on serial short-term contracts, leaving them open to exploitation by ambitious professors. [Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
However much the unis save by making themselves case studies in precarious employment, it's surely not worth it. If they're not driving away the most able of their future star performers it's a tribute to the "treat 'em mean to keep 'em keen" school of management.
But the greatest crime of our funding-obsessed unis is the way they've descended to short-changing their students, so as to cross-subsidise their research. At first they did this mainly by herding students into overcrowded lecture theatres and tutorials.
Lately they're exploiting new technology to achieve the introverted academic's greatest dream: minimal "face time" with those annoying pimply students who keep asking questions.[Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
PowerPoint is just about compulsory. Lectures are recorded and put on the website – or, failing that, those barely comprehensible "presentation" slides – together with other material sufficient to discourage many students – most of whom have part-time jobs – from bothering to attend lectures. Good thinking. [Does this ring any bells in Launceston?]
To be fair, an oddball minority of academics takes a pride in lecturing well. They get a lot of love back from their students, but little respect or gratitude from their peers. Vice-chancellors make a great show of awarding them tin medals, but it counts zilch towards their next promotion.
The one great exception to the 30-year quest to drive uni funding off the budget was Julia Gillard's ill-considered introduction of "demand-driven" funding of undergraduate places, part of a crazy plan to get almost all school-leavers going on to uni, when many would be better served going to TAFE.
The uni money-grubbers slashed their entrance standards, thinking of every excuse to let older people in, admitting as many students as possible so as to exploit the feds' fiscal loophole.
The result's been a marked lowering of the quality of uni degrees, and unis being quite unconscionable in their willingness to offer occupational degrees to far more people than could conceivably be employed in those occupations.

I suspect those vice-chancellors who've suggested that winding back the demand-determined system would be preferable to the proposed across-the-board cuts (and all those to follow) are right."
Ross Gittins is the Herald's economics editor.
COMMENT:  
If this is so and anywhere near being on the money why is that Launceston City Council is thinking that it's justifiable to give away public land to a 'money grabbing exploitative business'? 
There might well be a case to go into business with the university but think about it. You get to give the land away and the community takes on extra debt for more infrastructure and the university is EXEMPT from paying rates. How does that work
The aldermen didn't see the university coming, for whatever reason it seems that council management (the GM?) didn't look AND the ratepayer get the bill because the council can levy ratepayers. How does that work??
The university here is shaping up as being the 'enterprise-from-hell'  – the one that takes and does not give – and time is running out if there is a need to clip its wings!!

Saturday, 16 September 2017

Launceston's Dirty Tamar

"Separating Launceston's combined sewerage network at a 'cost of hundreds of millions of dollars' is not likely to significantly improve the health of the Tamar River, a TasWater senior engineer believes.

The river is subject to about 1000 sewerage outflows each year thanks to the city's unique combined sewer system – the second oldest in Australia to Sydney.

Consisting of one pipe for sewerage and stormwater, some of Launceston's brick-barrelled network dates back to the 1870s.

It works [??] by catching stormwater and sewerage in one pipe before pumping it to a treatment plant. 

In heavy rainfall the pipe can overflow, discharging raw sewage and stormwater into the river to prevent localised flooding.

Separating the system has long been mooted as a fix to faeces flowing into the river.

But TasWater treatment asset performance senior engineer Cameron Jessup said the entity's modelling showed splitting the network might not provide a value for money. 

"Work done to date doesn't suggest separation will give the best environmental outcomes," he said.

"The issues with separation was it was going to be very costly compared to the other upgrade options."

TasWater studies found the combined system contributed about 5 per cent of sediment load in the river, about 1 per cent of its nutrient load and 30 per cent of its pathogen. 

"The work we've done to date doesn't suggest a separated system is going to be a silver bullet," Mr Jessup said.

"You weren't going to see a marked reduction in solids load, you will see some reduction in that pathogen load – it's not going to be as significant as people expect."

The catchment area of the Tamar's tributary, South Esk, makes up about one-sixth of Tasmania's land mass. 

Forestry, farms and industrial pollution contributes to the quality of flow into the river.

"It's very difficult to put our hopes on one activity to significantly alter what's going on in the receiving environment," Mr Jessup said. 

"Spending hundreds of millions of dollars on separation doesn't seem to represent great value to our customers." 

Mr Jessup said Launceston's combined system was able to capture and treat the first rainfall flush, which pushes road contaminants and sediment into drains.

Under a separated system the stormwater would flow untreated into the river."


COMMENT

Well, well, I'm no engineer but I have watched the pointless separation of Trevallyn's stormwater from the sewer. The result is just as Hayden Johnson reports in The Examiner, Trevallyn's stormwater is sent speedily to the river gathering up all kinds of crap on its journey.

A lot of money, a lot of money, was spent by ratepayers "getting ready to hand it over to TASwater" and absolutely pointlessly. It remains an expensive and unfunny joke that nobody wants to talk about.

However, there were contractors who did very nicely out of the project and at the time more than the odd resident made that observation. Likewise, more recently on Bald Hill Rd – see http://baldhillroad7250.blogspot.com.au/ – spurious, and expensive, stormwater mismanagement has been undertaken by Launceston City Council and no amount of pleading with Mayor van Zetten and Robert Dobrzynski could influence the inept decision making.

You see under SECTION 65 the GM could determine anyone he liked to be an "expert" and delegate authority to whoever he liked under SECTION 62 of the Act.

As for Mayor van Zetten he was quite simply disinclined to intervene in the ratepayers' interest albeit that there were indications that West Tamar Council was prepared to entertain cost sharing. Along with his disinclination to amalgamate on terms suitable to adjoining jurisdictions, if his calls for 'resource sharing' seem hollow there seems to be quite a bit of evidence about that might lead you to think such things.

If The Tamar is to ever be dealt with in the way it needs to be Launceston's overblown council operation needs to be removed from the equation.

However, handing ownership of TASwater to the State Govt. is no way to go either!!

Rather TASwater needs to be corporatised as a Community Cooperative with the State's ratepayer directly holding shares. Tasmanian Govt. and Launceston's Councils over hundreds of years have looked the other way as The Tamar degraded!

It's time for a new approach!!

Ray Norman


Red tape, Richard Colbeck and Launceston's City Council

Contributions: How the short term rental market's two biggest players,
Airbnb and Stayz, impacted Tasmania's economy in the last year.

This agenda item for next Monday's Council meeting raises questions and quite probably more than are likely to be answered in the meeting. It is indeed "bemusing" that it might be Ald. Alexander who is making the running on this proposal. He is reportedly easily distracted from 'council business' when he is at the table and, apparently, as likely as not he can be found dashing off on more important business or 'twitering' during discussions he finds unimportant.

If Launceston's future can be seen as being more to do with tourism, and Airbnb accommodation is a part of that, and regulating this as a 'business activity' is in fact a State Govt. matter, it is unsurprising that questions about Ald. Alexander's 'interests' in the matter might arise.

Launceston's council operation has become charactorised by its blurring of its policymaking role and the council management's purpose. It is about time that the growing trend that's been especially in evidence over past few years was dealt with, and with some urgency. This blurring for whatever reason seems to suit management well enough and particularly so given that increasingly the Act virtually renders the elected representatives 'surplus to requirement'.

Ald. Alexander's intervention in the light of all this and his intervention in regard to 'Food Street' gets curiouser and curiouser. SEE: https://www.examiner.com.au/story/4896832/call-for-food-van-policy-at-city-council/?cs=95 Can these issues be linked – that is Airbnb and Food Street – and if there are links what are they?

Where are the broad scale and strategic policy determinations here? If this looks like a 'shot from the hip', is it just that, or is there something else going on here?

If there was a register of pecuniary interests such question might be more easily resolved. That is, other than under the protocol of declaring an interest in a matter. So, Richard Colbeck's bemusement is understandable as will be the constituency's bewilderment once these matters are given more scrutiny!  

Because of the blurring of the roles of management and the elected representatives, planning issues in Launceston all too easily become clouded in secrecy. In the end the wider community pays for the excesses of, and the aspirations of, developers.                                                                                                        

The Examiner's Story
Former federal tourism minister Richard Colbeck says he is "bemused" by a motion put forward at City of Launceston council to investigate its ability to regulate Airbnb, Stayz and other short-term accommodation facilities.

Mr Colbeck has been consulting privately with Stayz on both a state and national level.
He said attempting to regulate the innovation of the short-term accommodation industry was unnecessary and risked stifling innovation, as well as discouraging tourism in the region.
City of Launceston Alderman Darren Alexander put forward the notice of motion, to be considered in Monday's council meeting, asking the council to investigate its ability to administer regulation of Airbnb, Stayz and similar accommodation places.
Ald Alexander questioned whether the short-term rental market might discourage the larger traditional hotel sector from investing in the region.
Ald Alexander was contacted for comment on Friday.
New state regulations came into effect in July to regulate the short-term rental sector, reducing the amount of red tape people seeking to share their homes have to work through.
"Why is the instinct always to regulate up, when there is an opportunity to actually de-regulate some of the traditional sector?" Mr Colbeck said.
"What you're effectively doing is stifling innovation."
Mr Colbeck said the impact of the short-term rental accommodation sector on the traditional accommodation sector generated positive growth. He pointed to the rise of cheap airfares growing the airline economy and encouraging more people to fly as an example of a similar innovation growing the tourism economy.
A Deloitte report showed Airbnb brought in a contribution of $55 million to Tasmania's gross state product, and almost 600 jobs in 2015-2016. 
Across the state nearly 125,000 people stayed at Airbnbs through the year, spending $86 million during their visits.
Stayz visitors contributed nearly $22.1 million to the economy.
Rather than adding extra regulation at a local government level to the Airbnb sector, Mr Colbeck said it would be smarter for the large traditional sector, such as hotels and motels, to push for a red tape reduction to be in line with the state's short-term accommodation regulation.
"I was a bit bemused that here we have from Launceston – only a matter of weeks really since new regulatory framework came into place here in Tassie – that both the STR sector and local government participated in, there's proposals to add yet another layer of red tape," he said.

  

Friday, 15 September 2017

Coming to a Launceston Cafe near you


What Basil says!!


CLICK ON AN IMAGE TO ENLARGE

The Untouchables
Words fail me!!

For 7 years you, Janie, and the aldermen have been coned into the Robert Dobrynski mode of operation.

Say nothing!
Do nothing!
Just agree!

He took a $2million debt and turned it into a $20million debt  in 3 months and has left the ratepayers to pay!! Where has the aldermen’s accountability to ratepayers gone? Where has transparency gone?

Closed Council decision making remains supreme.

Why are 8 aldermen always silent at meetings week after week?

Yes, Robert taught you well!

Yes, Minister!!

Yes, yes and always beyond reproach!!